Introduction
Nearly everyone recognizes the smell of natural gas. That distinctive rotten egg odour alerts you to check that gas burners are turned off or lit when you’re cooking, or to get everyone out of the building if the source isn’t readily apparent. In this case study, we'll look back at a historical event that has had a significant impact on today's world.
With the increased usage of home-based gas products in our everyday lives from heating water, cooking food, lighting, camping and recreational uses, the inherent dangers are not always known nor are there warning signs heeded leading to serious damage and death if ignored.
Natural gas didn't always have an odour.
What you may not know is that natural gas is actually odourless and colourless. That distinctive smell comes from methyl mercaptan. Methyl mercaptan is a flammable, colourless gas that has a distinctive putrid smell. It’s added to commercial natural gas so that people can identify leaks, even very small ones.
Methyl mercaptan hasn’t always been added to natural gas. Like most safety upgrades, the status quo was changed after the need for improvement became tragically evident. In the case of adding an odour to make gas leaks easier to detect, the New London School explosion was a tipping point. On March 18, 1937, an estimated 294 people, mostly students, were killed and hundreds were injured when the New London Junior and Senior High School in Texas was levelled by a huge explosion.
In this scenario, we investigate using, and the building of the Cause Map, starting with a 5-Why for the New London TX School Explosion Cause Map:
As with any incident, when a root cause analysis is done, there are always multiple causes. To reduce costs, the school had tapped into a nearby raw natural gas line for heating. Raw natural gas was considered a waste product of oil drilling, so the oil companies turned a blind eye to the practice which was widespread in the region. The design of the school also played a role in the explosion. The school was built on a gentle slope with a 1meter void under length of the building. A leak developed and natural gas filled the void space. Students in some classrooms had reported headaches and burning eyes days before the disaster, but no one made the connection that natural gas collected under the school.
To obtain a copy of the New London TX School Explosion Cause Map 2-page PDF: Please contact SHERQ Risk Solutions to provide you with the 2 page cause map of this scenario.
Unaware of the danger, a shop teacher turned on an electric sander which is believed to have provided the spark that ignited the gas. The force of the explosion collapsed the main wing of the structure and lifted the roof off the building before it crashed back down.
Approximately 500 students and 40 teachers were in the school at time the explosion occurred. As horrific as this incident was, it could have been even worse. The first through fourth grades, who were housed in another building, had been let out early that day, so many students that normally attended the school weren’t on the campus when the explosion occurred.
Conclusion
This tragedy remains the worst catastrophe to occur inside a school in American history. Within weeks of the New London School explosion, the Texas Legislature passed a law requiring an odour to be added to natural gas to aid in the detection of leaks. Other states quickly followed suit. Every person who has said, “I think I smell natural gas” has benefited from the legacy of that tragedy.
As with any disaster, there are lessons that can be learned. Adding an odorant to natural gas has saved countless lives. But the application of the lessons highlighted by this explosion shouldn’t stop there. The idea of designing in ways to alert people of potential danger is relevant across industries. After all, it’s difficult to mitigate the danger you don’t even know is there.
Contact us today for assistance on Gas installation safety and root cause investigations done by our experts! Contact SHERQ Risk Solutions at www.sherqrisksolutions.co.za or email
me.
If you have any questions or comments, please feel free to
email me or
give me a call. Thank you for reading!
Stan Dismore
References